Thoughts on Superce...
 
Notifications
Clear all

How old do you think Mr. Juan Pablo Villalobos Maradiaga was? Poll is created on May 06, 2023

  
  
  
  
  
  
Poll results: How old do you think Mr. Juan Pablo Villalobos Maradiaga was?
Voter(s): 2
Poll is created on May 06, 2023
Yes, I think he was definitely 116  -  votes: 0 / 0%
0
0%
Maybe he was 116, but I have no idea  -  votes: 1 / 50%
1
50%
I think he was still an SC but between 110-115  -  votes: 0 / 0%
0
0%
I think he was between 105-109  -  votes: 0 / 0%
0
0%
I think he was 104 and the census listed his birthplace wrong  -  votes: 1 / 50%
1
50%
I think he was 103 or younger  -  votes: 0 / 0%
0
0%

Thoughts on Supercentenarians

5 Posts
3 Users
4 Likes
110 Views
Aquanaut_Chalk
(@aquanaut_chalk)
Fan
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 300
Topic starter  

I just wanted to ask everyone's thoughts on Juan Pablo Villalobos Maradiaga. I remember seeing his story on the news. It seems that after looking a little bit into his claim, a lot of people on the110club think he was born in 1913, making him 104 instead of his claimed age of 116. However, the birth place listed from the Juan Maradiaga born in 1913 does not match our 116 year old Juan Maradiaga. I have yet to see hard evidence to debunk his case, however 116 years & 99 days is extremely advanced and unlikely for a male. In my opinion I think there's about a 20% chance of him being the age claimed, against an 80% chance of him being false, only because of statistics and his advanced age. Still, even if he was only 104 or older, could he have possibly been the doyen of El Salvador? 104 seems a little young to be the doyen, but I'm not familiar with El Salvador's oldest men title holders before Santos Rivas. I'd like to know what everyone thinks. Should his case be re-opened? To my knowledge, he has not been debunked yet. He seems plausible enough to be further investigated. 

First Supercentenarian I learned about: Salvatore Caruso (1905-2015)
Favorite Male Supercentenarian: Juan Vicente Pérez Mora (1909-Living)
Favorite Female Supercentenarian: Tomiko Itooka (1908-Living)
Favorite Supercentenarian Ever: Jiroemon Kimura (1897-2013)
Favorite Centenarian Ever: Nellie Wright (1907-2016)


   
diego reacted
Quote
(@michal1095)
Fan
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 1
 

I voted 104. Definitely he doesn't looks like supercentenarian, especially 116.


   
Ale76 reacted
ReplyQuote
Mendocino
(@mendocino)
Fan
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 336
 

Posted by: @michal1095

I voted 104. Definitely he doesn't looks like supercentenarian, especially 116.

The 1913 birth record found is almost certainly not a match, though, since it's quite far away from his claimed place of birth (Moncagua, San Miguel). The 1913 born baby is also illegitimate, and registered as "Juan Maradiaga". Of course, it's very possible that Juan Pablo Villalobos Maradiaga was also born to an unmarried mother, but a person with the name "Juan Pablo" would almost never be referred to as just "Juan". This is because Pablo is his "real" name, whereas Juan is more of a decorative name (similarly to Juan Vicente Pérez Mora). This 1906 record is more likely to be a match, since it's closer to his claimed place of birth and matches his "main" first name, but there's no way to know for sure without confirming his mother's name. A 1906 birthyear would also mean he was around 16 in 1922, when he claims his first child was born - this is obviously quite young and probably would've been before he married, but that wouldn't be too uncommon for the time period (Santos Rivas actually fathered his first child when he was only around 15).

 

Profile picture: Marita Camacho Quiros (1911-Present)


   
ReplyQuote
Aquanaut_Chalk
(@aquanaut_chalk)
Fan
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 300
Topic starter  

@mendocino wow that's interesting. So if the 1906 birth record is correct, he would have probably still been the oldest man in El Salvador at the time of his death.

First Supercentenarian I learned about: Salvatore Caruso (1905-2015)
Favorite Male Supercentenarian: Juan Vicente Pérez Mora (1909-Living)
Favorite Female Supercentenarian: Tomiko Itooka (1908-Living)
Favorite Supercentenarian Ever: Jiroemon Kimura (1897-2013)
Favorite Centenarian Ever: Nellie Wright (1907-2016)


   
ReplyQuote
Aquanaut_Chalk
(@aquanaut_chalk)
Fan
Joined: 1 year ago
Posts: 300
Topic starter  

I was thinking about researching a new unvalidated supercentenarian. Does anyone know if Mrs. Rosa Zoila Higuera Velandia's age has been debunked? She seems like an interesting case to research. I don't know anything about her yet though, I've only found about her case yesterday. 

First Supercentenarian I learned about: Salvatore Caruso (1905-2015)
Favorite Male Supercentenarian: Juan Vicente Pérez Mora (1909-Living)
Favorite Female Supercentenarian: Tomiko Itooka (1908-Living)
Favorite Supercentenarian Ever: Jiroemon Kimura (1897-2013)
Favorite Centenarian Ever: Nellie Wright (1907-2016)


   
diego reacted
ReplyQuote
Share: